Is ISB better than IIM?
- Goalisb
- May 16
- 29 min read
Updated: Jul 5
Yes, if the applicant has a work experience of upto 4 or 5 years and is considering a one year MBA program, ISB is a good choice for him. However if the applicant has a work experience of more than 5 years he / she is also eligible for the IIM one year MBA for executives, where the number of options for the applicant increases. For applicants with a work experience of around 8 years the IIM Executive MBA programs maybe quite suitable as the average work experience in the IIM one year MBA class is around 8 to 8.5 years.
Apart from these, there are also differences in the class size, class average age, curriculum and program structure which would be important for the individual learners to decide on the program according to their personal preferences. We are discussing these in detail in this blog.
ISB and IIM are top ranked schools in India and worldwide. IIM and ISB are however different in may ways like the average class profile, work experience, kind of industries that graduates get opportunities post MBA and functional roles offered in the placements at IIM vs ISB. If one goes by the rankings above ISB definitely stands a level higher than IIM. However, to address the question of is ISB Hyderabad better than IIM, we will take a standard roadmap of what the program offers and the program structure. To decide between ISB vs IIM for a specific profile depends on what the applicant is seeking from the MBA program.
ISB vs IIM: Key Comparison Criteria to Guide Your MBA Decision
ISB vs IIM Batch Size & Classroom Dynamics
Why Batch Size Shapes the MBA Experience
Batch size is more than a number. It shapes how visible you are in class, how many recruiters you interact with, and how wide your post-MBA network stretches. It also influences classroom participation, competition, and culture.
ISB vs IIM One-Year MBA Batch Size (2025)
Program | Batch Size |
ISB PGP | 816 |
IIMA PGPX | 158 |
IIMB EPGP | 82 |
IIMC MBAEx | 80 |
IIML IPMX | 110 |
IIMI EPGP | 74 |
What That Means for You:
ISB offers the largest one-year MBA cohort in India. You get more alumni connections, more peer diversity, and more recruiter visibility — but you may have to work harder to stand out.
IIMs, with batch sizes between 74–158, offer more personalized academic attention, stronger cohort intimacy, and more faculty-student interaction.
ISB vs IIM Work Experience Range & Averages in Class
Why Experience Range (and Global Exposure) Matters
In a one-year MBA, you're not learning the basics — you're learning from each other. The breadth of experience and international exposure in your cohort can drastically shift your perspective on global business problems, leadership, and adaptability.
Average Work Experience – Class of 2025
Program | Avg. Work Exp | International Work Experience |
ISB PGP | 4.1 years | ~7% of the class |
IIMA PGPX | 7.5 years | 32% of the class |
IIMB EPGP | 7 years | 21% |
IIMC MBAEx | 8.5 years | ~10% |
IIML IPMX | 8.7 years | 14% |
IIMI EPGP | 8.4 years | 15% |
Work Experience Range (Across Programs)
ISB: 2 to 24 years
IIM One-Year MBAs: Typically 5 to 18+ years
What This Means for You:
ISB is best suited for professionals early in their career arc, looking for career acceleration or functional/industry switches. International exposure in the class is relatively limited but growing each year.
IIM programs, especially IIMA and IIMB, attract professionals with extensive global work experience, often in leadership roles across geographies. This adds global context to classroom discussions — particularly valuable for those seeking regional leadership or global mobility post-MBA.
Industry and Function Class profile ISB vs IIM - Who will you learn with in 2025
Why Peer Group Matters in a One-Year MBA?
In a one-year MBA, your peers shape your learning as much as your professors do. You’re solving case studies, building startup ideas, and debating global business in real-time with people from different industries and career stages. So the composition of the class matters — deeply.
This comparison of the incoming class profiles from ISB and top IIM one-year MBAs (PGPX, EPGP, MBAEx, IPMX, and EPGP at IIMI) reveals three very different ecosystems.
Functional Background: What Roles They Come From
The ISB cohort has a wide functional base:
Sales/Marketing: 14%
Product/Program Management: ~13%
Finance & Strategy: 13%
Operations/Supply Chain: ~10%
Analytics/Data Science: 6%
Consulting: 14%
At IIM one-year MBAs, functional diversity varies:
IIML: Nearly 30% from operations and project management
IIMA/IIMB: Strong showings in product, finance, and consulting
IIMC/IIMI: More infrastructure, public sector, and core engineering profiles
🔍 Insight:ISB offers a multi-functional cohort — peer learning across business verticals is richer.IIMs offer functionally mature ecosystems, where depth and seniority in specific domains dominate.
Functional Background – Roles Before the MBA
Function | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMB EPGP | IIML IPMX | IIMI EPGP |
Consulting | 14% | 19 students | 8 | 10% | 12% |
Sales & Marketing | 14% | 20 students | 3 | 9% | 9% |
Product/Program Mgmt | ~12–14% | 53 total | 24 total | 15% | 12% |
Operations/Supply Chain | ~10% | 19 students | 12 | 29% | 19% |
Finance & Strategy | 13% | 14 students | 4 | 10% | 15% |
Tech/Engineering | ~10% | 14+ students | 5–8 | 10% | 11% |
Analytics/Data Science | 5–7% | 8 students | 2 | — | 8% |
Takeaway:
ISB builds cross-functional diversity, ideal for peer learning.
IIM programs lean toward domain specialists and functionally mature professionals.
Industry Background: Sectoral Exposure
At ISB, the incoming class is industry-fluid. It includes consultants, product managers, tech leads, entrepreneurs, and public sector professionals. The top sectors represented are:
Consulting: 37%
Tech/IT/ITES: 21%
BFSI: ~10%
With niche representation in healthcare, energy, media, and non-profits
In contrast, IIM one-year MBAs reflect a cohort that's more deeply embedded in their industries:
IIMA, IIMI, and IIMC: Strong presence in manufacturing, infra, energy, and public sector
IIML and IIMB: Blend of tech, consulting, and operations leaders
Industry Background in Class - ISB vs IIM
Sector | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMB EPGP | IIMC MBAEx | IIML IPMX | IIMI EPGP |
Tech/IT/ITES | 21% | 18% | 13% | 12.5% | 28% | 18% |
Consulting | 37% | 16% | 7% | 7.5% | 28% | 5% |
BFSI | ~10% | 20% | 6% | 10% | 12% | 11% |
Manufacturing/Engg | ~5–7% | 20% | 13% | 5% | 14% | 15% |
Energy/Infra | ~3–5% | 8% | 7% | 17.5% | 9% | 15% |
Public Sector/Defence | ~2% | 20% | 7% | 2.5% | 5% | 8% |
Takeaway:
ISB is industry-fluid, with strong representation in consulting, tech, and product.
IIM programs bring domain depth, especially in public sector, infra, energy, and core engineering.
Which Peer Group Fits You Better IIM vs ISB?
Question | ISB PGP | IIM One-Year MBAs |
Are you 25–30 with 3–6 years of experience? | Ideal | Often under-experienced |
Are you 30–35 with 8+ years and team leadership? | Still welcome | Core target audience |
Are you looking for diverse classmates from 20+ sectors? | Strong mix | Smaller but high-caliber group |
Which is better ISB or IIM?
The IIMs represent academic excellence in India. Founded in the 1960s, they have maintained their reputation over the decades. Each IIM is autonomous, fostering diverse academic cultures.
ISB, although much younger, has rapidly gained prestige. It was founded with the vision to bring international education standards to India. ISB is well-regarded for its innovative approach and research-driven environment.
The branding of these institutions plays a key role. IIMs are often associated with tradition and extensive history. Meanwhile, ISB is seen as dynamic and globally inclined.
Both institutions attract top-tier faculty from around the world. This enriches their educational offerings with diverse expertise. Faculty members at both IIMs and ISB also engage actively in research.
Notably, alumni from these institutions hold influential positions globally. Their success stories add to the allure of IIMs and ISB. This influence bolsters the reputation of both institutions internationally.
While IIMs have long dominated the business education scene, ISB's rise showcases India's evolving educational landscape. The country's business education continues to expand and adapt to global changes.
These institutions' prestige affects student choice. Potential students often weigh historical reputation against modernity. The decision often hinges on an individual's career aspirations and learning preferences.
4. What is the Salary of IIM vs ISB?
Salaries are a major factor in the IIM vs. ISB debate. Both institutions offer attractive financial returns post-graduation. Let's explore the specifics of these salary outcomes.
IIMs traditionally command high salary packages, particularly in finance and consulting. The robust alumni network and brand recognition boost employability. Graduates often secure positions with leading multinational firms.
ISB, however, has carved a niche in entrepreneurship and tech fields. It offers competitive salaries, with a focus on innovation-driven roles. ISB's global curriculum aligns well with these high-growth sectors.
The highest salaries at IIMs can surpass those at ISB in specific industries. Yet, ISB's average salary can be impressive, particularly in tech roles. This reflects the changing demands of the global job market.
Additionally, the return on investment (ROI) from both schools is significant. Students typically recover educational expenses quickly due to lucrative packages. This makes both IIMs and ISB attractive for potential enrollees.
Ultimately, the choice depends on career goals and sector preferences. Prospective students should weigh salary trends alongside personal ambitions. This approach ensures an informed and strategic educational decision.
Comparing IIM vs ISB in Salary for the latest class profiles:
Parameter | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMC MBAEx | IIMB EPGP | IIML IPMX | IIM Indore EPGP |
Median Salary (INR LPA) | 34.5 | 36.2 | 32.28 | 34 | 32 | ~28 |
Mean Salary (INR LPA) | 34.21 | 36.2 | 32.68 | 34 | 32 | ~28 |
Key Sectors | Consulting, Technology | Technology, Consulting | IT, Oil & Gas | Technology, BFSI | IT, Consulting | BFSI, Energy |
IIMA PGPX Placements Trends Over The Last 10 Years
Year | IIMA PGPX Mean | IIMA PGPX Median | Maximum Earning Potential |
2019 | 2391997 | 2339172 | 3035708 |
2020 | 2650641 | 2500000 | 3336247 |
2021 | 2626071 | 2500000 | 3244547 |
2022 | 3053772 | 3000000 | 3864049 |
2023 | 2878615 | 2782259 | 3568276 |
ISB Placement Trends over the last 10 years
ISB Class | 80% Mean Salary Offered | 80% Median Salary Offered |
Class of 2019 | 24,35,915 | 24,02,449 |
Class of 2020 | 25,06,434 | 24,10,000 |
Class of 2021 | 27,13,055 | 27,00,000 |
Class of 2022 | 32,76,366 | 31,00,000 |
Class of 2023 | 33,25,742 | 32,00,000 |
Get in touch with an experienced MBA admission consultant at GOALisB for a profile evaluation or application assistance.
Looking to venture into tech or product roles post ISB MBA? ISB MBA career options in product management equip students with skills needed to lead in tech-focused industries. See what the program offers for this sought-after career path.
5. Prominent Sectors in Placements at IIM vs ISB differ:
Over the years we have observed with our admits that the one year MBA programs whether IIM vs ISB both have facilitated both role change and sector change for applicants. When we look closely we find the recruitment patterns as follows at IIM vs ISB:
At IIM Executive MBA the largest sector pool recruited was the IT sector, followed by online services, then consulting and then BFSI amongst other sectors which include energy, Pharma, manufacturing, FMCG etc.
In terms of function, the majority placements took place in marketing roles, followed by operations and general management at IIM Executive MBA.
On the other hand at ISB PGP a large proportion of hiring takes place in consulting, followed by e-commerce, FMCG and retail and finance/ financial services.
ISB vs IIM Placements: Companies and Functional Roles Offered
Placement success varies between IIMs and ISB, shaped by sector strengths. Each attracts a range of top-tier companies offering diverse roles. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for potential students.
IIMs witness strong demand from consulting and finance sectors. Firms like McKinsey, and BCG are frequent recruiters from the two year MBA at IIM. They offer roles focused on strategy, finance, and management.
ISB graduates often find opportunities in tech, healthcare, and entrepreneurship. Companies like Google, Amazon, and several startups actively recruit. Leadership and strategic roles are common in these industries.
The diversity of roles enhances the career trajectory for graduates. IIM graduates often move into senior management and consulting positions. Conversely, ISB graduates enjoy roles in digital transformation and innovation.
Both institutions offer robust placement support and career services. This includes resume workshops, interview preparation, and networking events. Students are well-prepared to meet industry expectations.
Placement outcomes influence the value proposition of each school. The right fit aligns with career aspirations and sector interests. Understanding company affiliations helps tailor applications and career goals.
Common Job Titles Offered at IIM vs ISB Placements According to the Linkedin MBA Ranking 2024
Institution | Common Job Titles |
Indian School of Business | Product Manager, Program Manager, Management Consultant |
IIM Ahmedabad | Product Manager, Business Analyst, Program Manager |
IIM Calcutta | Product Manager, Management Analyst, Business Consultant |
IIM Bangalore | Product Manager, Program Manager, Business Analyst |
IIM Lucknow | Product Manager, Program Manager, Business Consultant |
IIM Indore | Product Manager, Business Analyst, Investment Banking Analyst |
Salary progression in Placements at IIM vs ISB also differs:
The CTC enhancement at ISB for graduates across a range of work experience for the class of 2021 has been observed as below:
For graduates with a work experience of 2 years to 3 years the hike in CTC post an ISB MBA has been recorded at close to 275%.
Graduates with an experience in the range of 5 to 6 years achieved an enhancement of approximately 145% in their CTC post the ISB MBA.
This evaluation of IIM vs ISB might be important for some applicants who are quite sector and role focused in their MBA investment decision. With a specialized approach for each industry, ISB welcomes applicants from oil and gas. Here’s how the ISB application process for oil and gas professionals can help showcase industry-specific leadership and technical skills.
Career Services Rank: ISB vs IIM One-Year MBA Programs (FT MBA 2025)
Program | Career Services Rank (FT 2025) |
ISB – Indian School of Business | 19 |
IIM Ahmedabad (PGPX) | 43 |
IIM Bangalore (EPGP) | 60 |
IIM Calcutta (MBAEx) | 18 |
IIM Indore (EPGP) | 52 |
IIM Lucknow (IPMX) | Not ranked |
Key Insights
ISB ranks 19th globally for Career Services. ISB rankings are an indicator of its strong placement infrastructure, recruiter partnerships, and student support.
IIM Calcutta slightly edges ISB at 18, despite having a smaller batch and more senior peer group — showing the strength of targeted placement support.
IIM Ahmedabad and IIM Bangalore — though globally prestigious — rank lower (43 and 60 respectively), reflecting a more hybrid placement model where senior candidates also rely on network-based job hunting.
IIM Lucknow is not listed in the FT rankings for Career Services in 2025.
ISB vs IIM: Alumni Network Strength
FT Global MBA 2025: Alumni Network Ranking
Program | Alumni Network Rank (FT 2025) |
ISB (PGP) | 4th globally |
IIM Ahmedabad (PGPX) | 33rd |
IIM Bangalore (EPGP) | 35th |
IIM Calcutta (MBAEx) | 32nd |
IIM Indore (EPGP) | Not ranked |
IIM Lucknow (IPMX) | Not ranked |
Insight: ISB’s alumni network ranks 4th globally, ahead of most Ivy League and European peers — a clear signal of alumni effectiveness, mobility, and influence. The IIMs follow in the 30s, still respectable, but indicating less international or cross-industry network activation.
The alumni networks of IIMs and ISB are vast and influential. They play a crucial role in shaping students' career paths. Access to a robust network opens numerous opportunities.
IIM alumni often hold prominent positions globally. This extensive network can be a powerful resource. It offers insights and connections that help in career advancement.
ISB alumni are equally distinguished, with strong industry presence. They actively participate in mentorship and recruitment activities. This involvement greatly benefits current students.
Both networks foster lifelong professional relationships. They provide a platform for sharing experiences and opportunities. Alumni interactions often lead to career breakthroughs.
These networks also facilitate collaboration across sectors. They help in navigating career transitions and exploring new fields. The alumni communities provide support long after graduation.
Overall, the alumni networks of IIMs and ISB are invaluable assets. They significantly contribute to the career success of students and graduates. The connections and support they offer cannot be understated.
Alumni Network Rank:
IIM Ahmedabad: Ranked 16.
IIM Bangalore: Ranked 39.
IIM Lucknow: Ranked 23.
ISB: Ranked 8.
IIM vs ISB is a question that we face almost other day and the clear answer is that both the institutes are stalwarts in delivering World class MBA education in India. Beyond that what you make of the education is upto you. In terms of the course content there is hardly a lot of comparison between IIM vs ISB as both enrich the graduates in experience, network, contemporary management education and provide the MBA graduates a sea of opportunities.
ISB Placements boast excellent post-graduation outcomes across industries. Learn about the average salaries, top recruiting firms, and sector-wise placement stats.
10. Which is better ISB or IIM Global Ranking?
Rankings play a crucial role when evaluating business schools like IIM and ISB. They help establish the reputation and perception of an institution. Understanding how these rankings work is essential for prospective students.
IIM and ISB often feature prominently in both national and global rankings. These rankings factor in various criteria including academic excellence, faculty quality, and placement records. Both institutions are well-respected, although the emphasis might vary.
The methodology behind these rankings can offer insights into an institution's strengths. For example, certain rankings may prioritize research output. Others might focus more on employability and alumni success stories.
A major advantage of high rankings is the global recognition it affords graduates. Prestige from top-ranked institutions can open doors worldwide. It also enhances the value of the education received at such schools.
Rankings are not the sole indicators of quality, but they contribute significantly. They provide a quantitative measure that complements qualitative evaluations. Understanding them can help align educational choices with career ambitions.
Both IIM and ISB have been lauded for their comprehensive programs. The rigorous academic environment is a common point of praise. Their approach to holistic development is often highlighted in rankings.
Understanding the rankings involves:
Criteria: Academic excellence, placement success, research output.
Global vs. National: Different weight for international aspirations.
Reputation Impact: Influence on career prospects and networks.
While rankings are informative, they should be one of many factors in decision-making. Personalized fit and career alignment are equally important considerations. An understanding of rankings can be a useful part of evaluating these premier institutions.
Comparing the latest Global ISB vs IIM Ranking:
Institution | FT Global MBA Rank (2025) | QS Asia MBA Rank (2025) | LinkedIn India Alumni Rank* |
ISB | 27 | 15 | 6 |
IIM Ahmedabad | 47 | 9 | 19 |
IIM Bangalore | 52 | 8 | 27 |
IIM Calcutta | 67 | 11 | 24 |
IIM Lucknow | 85 | – | 29 |
IIM Indore | Not ranked in FT 2025 | 23 | 46 |
Ranking Movement: FT MBA Rankings (2024 to 2025)
Institution | FT Rank 2024 | FT Rank 2025 | Change |
ISB | 31 | 27 | ↑ 4 |
IIM Ahmedabad | 41 | 47 | ↓ 6 |
IIM Bangalore | 47 | 52 | ↓ 5 |
IIM Calcutta | 67 | 67 | — |
IIM Lucknow | 85 | 85 | — |
IIM Indore | 89 | Not ranked | — |
Trend Insight:
ISB is the only Indian B-school to climb in FT 2025, now ranked 27th globally and 5th in Asia.
IIM A & B saw mild dips, while IIM Calcutta and Lucknow held steady.
IIM Indore dropped out of the FT Top 100.
Evaluating, Is ISB worth the high fees? This guide outlines the value of ISB’s network, career placements, and post-MBA earnings, helping you evaluate the return on investment.
IIM vs ISB QS Global MBA Rankings Asia 2025:
ISB ranks 15th in QS Global MBA Rankings Asia 2025
IIMA ranks 9th in QS Global MBA Rankings Asia 2025
IIMB ranks 8th in QS Global MBA Rankings Asia 2025
IIMC ranks 11th in QS Global MBA Rankings Asia 2025
If you consider the FT Global MBA rankings 2023, ISB does rank higher than IIM, however the response to IIM vs ISB would be different for every individual.
FT Ranked Indian MBA Programs:
The FT MBA ranking 2025 positions 8 Indian schools as leading institutions of education. In all we observe that the MBA programs in India rank the third in terms of a country represented in the ranking.
Indian School of Business (ISB) – PGP
FT Global MBA Rank: 27
Alumni Network Rank: 8
Career Progress Rank: 2
Salary Increase: 229% (Highest in Asia)
Weighted Salary: $174,421
Employment Rate: 100%
Female Students: 40%
International Students: 1%
QS Asia Rank: 15
ROI (QS): 71.4
FT Global MBA Rank: 47
Career Progress Rank: 1st globally
Salary Increase: 141%
Weighted Salary: $194,595
Employment Rate: 99%
Female Students: 22%
International Students: 1%
QS Asia Rank: 9
ROI (QS): 80.6
FT Global MBA Rank: 52
Career Progress Rank: 3
Salary Increase: 169%
Weighted Salary: $167,425
Employment Rate: 100%
Female Students: 12%
International Students: 1%
QS Asia Rank: 8
ROI (QS): 84.8
FT Global MBA Rank: 67
Career Progress Rank: 9
Salary Increase: 127%
Weighted Salary: $163,075
Employment Rate: 99%
Female Students: 10%
International Students: 3%
QS Asia Rank: 11
FT Global MBA Rank: 71
Salary Increase: 123%
Weighted Salary: $158,607
Employment Rate: 100%
Female Students: 19%
Career Progress Rank: 29
International Students: 3%
QS Asia Rank: Not ranked
FT Notes: Highest improvement from previous year, up from rank 85 in 2024
FT Global MBA Rank: 69
Salary Increase: 135%
Weighted Salary: $161,012
Employment Rate: 100%
Female Students: 17%
Career Progress Rank: 52
International Students: 2%
QS Asia Rank: 23
FT Global MBA Rank: 86
Salary Increase: 108%
Weighted Salary: $142,022
Employment Rate: 100%
Female Students: 18%
Career Progress Rank: 38
International Students: 1%
QS Asia Rank: Not ranked
FT Global MBA Rank: 83
Salary Increase: 98%
Weighted Salary: $141,554
Employment Rate: 100%
Female Students: 18%
Career Progress Rank: 44
International Students: 1%
Key Insights of MBA Rankings Comparison for QS 2025 and FT 2025:
Ranking Emphasis Differences:
FT focuses heavily on salary metrics and career outcomes
QS emphasizes academic reputation and diversity
Consistent Strengths:
Career progression (especially IIM-A)
Employment rates (near 100%)
Faculty quality (100% doctorates)
Areas of Divergence:
International diversity (low scores in QS)
Research/thought leadership (stronger in QS)
Entrepreneurship (new metric in QS)
Notable Trends:
Higher positions in FT for career-based metrics
Lower scores in QS for diversity metrics
Strong ROI scores across both rankings
ISB shows highest salary increase but lower overall QS rank
11. Admission process for the IIM vs ISB program differs:
Eligibility for ISB vs IIM:
ISB MBA programs and One Year MBA from IIM Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Calcutta are definitely programs befitting professionals with experience. In terms of minimum eligibility criteria for years of work experience for ISB vs IIM executive MBA programs compare as below:
ISB MBA eligibility: Minimum of 24 months of work experience.
Executive MBA at IIM Ahmedabad: Minimum 4 years of work experience
Executive MBA at IIM Bangalore: Minimum 5 years of work experience
Executive MBA at IIM Calcutta: Minimum 5 years of work experience
Test Score requirements for the IIM Executive MBA vs the ISB:
If we compare the score requirements for the IIM vs ISB there is a slight difference among the individual schools as below:
ISB: Accepts the GMAT score or the GRE score
IIMA PGPX : accepts the GMAT score or the GRE score
IIMB EPGP : accepts the GMAT score of the GRE score
IIMC MBAEX : accepts only the GMAT score
Average GMAT scores for the Class of 2022 for IIM vs ISB
GMAT score for ISB : 710, GMAT score range 600 to 780
IIMA PGPX : 701
IIMB EPGP: 690, maximum 770
IIMC MBAEX: 685 , maximum 750
Average GRE score for the Class of 2023 for IIM vs ISB
ISB : 328, GRE score range 311 to 335
IIMA PGPX : 323
12. Comparing IIM vs ISB Selection Process:
Step / Component | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMB EPGP | IIMC MBAEx |
Application Form | Online form with academics, awards, etc. | Online form only (essays come later if shortlisted) | Online form | Online form |
Essays | 3 mandatory essays | Not in stage 1, 3 essays post shortlisting | 1 mandatory essay | 1 mandatory + 1 optional essay |
LORs | 1 professional recommender | Not required | 2 professional recommenders | 2 professional recommenders |
Test Score | GMAT or GRE | GMAT or GRE | GMAT or GRE | GMAT only |
Resume | Required (ISB-formatted) | Required (standard CV format) | Not required | Not required |
Shortlisting Criteria | Holistic (GMAT/GRE, essays, profile) | Academic + GMAT + Work Ex threshold then essays | GMAT/GRE + experience + essay + LORs | GMAT + profile screening |
Pre-Interview Round | On The Spot Essays | Submit 3 essays and resume after shortlist | WAT (Written Ability Test) | None |
Interview Format | Conversational, career-focused | Extempore + Panel Interview | WAT + Panel Interview | Panel Interview |
Post-Interview Outcome | Rolling, waitlist, or admit | Admit or waitlist | Admit or waitlist | Admit or waitlist |
Insights
ISB admission process requires a complete story up front — resume, essays, LOR, and test score are evaluated holistically.
IIMA PGPX does not ask for essays initially — they focus on test score and work experience depth. Essays only come after shortlist, followed by extempore and interview.
IIMB EPGP is the only one with written IIM WAT component before the interview — and values LORs and structured writing.
IIMC MBAEx (and similar IIML, IIMI models) are GMAT-only, with heavier document evaluation early on but no resume or WAT requirement.
Interview ISB vs IIM Interview Process: What Really Happens in the Room
Why the Interview Format Matters
For mid-career MBA applicants, the interview is not just about fit — it’s often the final hurdle that decides admission. While your application tells your story, the interview tests how authentic, strategic, and self-aware you are when challenged in real time.
The format, tone, and expectation in the ISB and IIM interview rooms vary significantly.
ISB vs IIM Interview Process Comparison
Component | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMB EPGP | IIMC MBAEx |
Mode | Virtual / In-person (hybrid) | In-person only (at multiple cities, pre-assigned slots) | In-person (WAT + Interview on same day) | In-person (single interview round) |
Interview Panel | 2–3 alums | 2–3 faculty members | 2–3 member faculty panel & alumni | 2–3 faculty &alumni panel |
Duration | 25–35 minutes | 20–30 minutes | 20–30 minutes | 20–30 minutes |
Style | Conversational, narrative-led | Academic, analytical, career-deep-dive + extempore | Competency-focused, structured + WAT before interview | Straightforward, panel-led conversation |
Extempore Component | No, includes on the spot essays | Yes (1–2 minute prep, 2–3 minute speech) | No | No |
WAT (Written Ability Test) | Not applicable | Not included | Yes — 20–30 min essay | Not applicable |
Common Evaluation Themes | Career clarity, leadership, values, maturity | Depth of experience, structured thinking, response to pressure | Strategic insight, logic, communication | Career goals, industry knowledge, overall fit |
Scoring | Holistic panel evaluation | Rubric-based with weight for extempore and structured Q&A | Written + interview weighted jointly | Panel consensus-driven |
What Each Interview Looks Like:
Focus is on "Who are you becoming?"
Panel is warm but probing — they’ll test the consistency between your application and your responses.
Questions often cover:
Career goals
Key decisions and turning points
Leadership examples
Industry awareness
No case study, extempore, or written test.
The most academic and intense among all IIMs.
You are first given a random topic for an extempore speech (1–2 minutes to prepare).
Then a deep dive into your functional knowledge, challenges handled, and even macroeconomic opinions.
Often ends with situational or ethical questions.
IIMB – EPGP Interview
Begins with a Written Ability Test (WAT) — candidates write a short essay (typically 20–30 minutes).
The interview explores your reasoning in the WAT, your leadership path, and problem-solving frameworks.
IIM Interview Questions are competency-focused, with emphasis on self-awareness and structure.
IIMC – MBAEx Interview
More direct and evaluative — less pressure than IIMA, but still serious.
Common areas:
Career milestones
Role evolution
Motivation for MBA now
No WAT or extempore, but deep questioning on functional achievements.
Best for professionals who are grounded, realistic, and clear about their leadership evolution.
The interview process at IIM vs ISB differs mainly in terms of the pattern of interaction however, is a bit different for each. While IIM A starts the interview with an extempore discussion, IIM B and IIM C differ in the sequence of the events during an interview. The ISB interview categorically moves around the work experience, and it is an inquiry into the fit and the preparedness of the applicant for the ISB PGP program. IIM or ISB both evaluate the depth of the past work experience of the applicant, the justification of the need of an MBA for the future career path along with a clear set growth plan to achieve one's post MBA goals.
Location preference of the applicants:
According to locations they prefer applicants can choose from various programs across India.
1. ISB PGP (Post Graduate Program) at Hyderabad and Mohali
2. Executive MBA from IIM Ahmedabad - PGPX (Post Graduate Program for Executives)
3. Executive MBA from IIM Bangalore - EPGP (Executive Post Graduate Program)
4. Executive MBA from IIM Calcutta - MBAeX (Post Graduate Program for Executives)
5. Executive MBA from IIM Lucknow - IPMX (International Programme in Management for Executives)
15. Value For Money rank ISB vs IIM:
Indian School of Business (ISB):
Value for Money Rank: 55
IIM Ahmedabad:
Value for Money Rank: 29
IIM Bangalore:
Value for Money Rank: 39
IIM Calcutta:
Value for Money Rank: 36
IIM Lucknow:
Value for Money Rank: 45
Among the IIMs, IIM Ahmedabad ranks the highest in Value for Money at 29.
ISB, with a rank of 55, trails behind IIM Ahmedabad, Bangalore, and Calcutta but ranks higher than several international schools.
Value for Money rankings typically consider the tuition cost, salary outcomes, and additional career benefits provided by the program, highlighting differences in perceived ROI between ISB and IIM programs.
ROI of the IIM Executive MBA or the ISB:
The ROI of an Ivy league program is not rightly judged in the first year, so comparing placements is a very skewed approach to enumerate the value addition that these programs provide.
The actual ROI which most MBA graduates passing out from these institutions would agree comes after 2-3 years post MBA. That is when one spans out into the enigma of the institution that they have graduated from.
This makes the discussion of whether ISB Hyderabad is better than IIM quite irrelevant if one considers it in slightly long term. It would be more realistic to prepare well to spell out your goals and how you wish to achieve them.
16. Degree status of IIM vs ISB MBA
The IIM one year MBA in India programs award degrees approved by the AICTE till date, however ISB not being a university cannot grant degrees to its graduates.
Finally, there is no doubt that the industry acceptance of IIM executive MBA and the ISB PGP is well established in India and abroad due to the widespread reach and success of their alumni. Choosing on the basis of the criteria enumerated above, IIM vs ISB definitely reaps rewards for future career growth.
17. Curriculum Comparison at IIM vs ISB:
The curriculum at both the Executive MBA from IIM and ISB PGP are based on a mix of core and elective courses. International exposure, group work, team projects, well established faculty, leadership training - all gear up students for achieving their future career goals.
A one-year MBA is fast-paced, but the way each school structures that intense year can significantly shape your growth. Here's a detailed comparison of the curriculum design, elective flexibility, and global exposure offered by ISB, IIMA PGPX, and IIMB EPGP.
Curriculum Design & Pedagogy
Feature | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMB EPGP |
Pedagogy | Mixed: lectures, case discussions, experiential, action learning | Case method dominant, supported by simulations, games, projects | Mix of case studies, classroom learning, industry speakers |
Core Curriculum | Cross-functional foundation in leadership, analytics, decision-making | Strong foundation in general management across strategy, finance, marketing, ops, economics | Emphasis on leadership, strategy, operations, and communication |
Electives | Wide range across marketing, finance, ops, analytics, product, entrepreneurship | Rich elective pool, choice-based specialization, strong academic freedom | Electives across programs including general MBA and Business Analytics |
Learning Personalization | Career coaching + flexibility to specialize via electives & global modules | Electives post-core with career-aligned selection; Capstone integrates all learnings | Access to electives across programs; integrated capstone project |
Is Indian School of Business better than IIM?
ISB is highly modular and allows early-career professionals to explore multiple tracks or deep-dive into one. IIMA PGPX focuses on deep academic rigor and learning through real-time decision frameworks. IIMB EPGP is compact but enriched with access to electives across departments and practical industry connects.
Global Exposure Comparison of IIM vs ISB
Feature | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMB EPGP |
Global Immersion | Optional International Exchange Program with 50+ schools | Mandatory International Immersion Programme (IIP) – 2 weeks | Mandatory Global Immersion (GNAM) – partner school immersion |
Partner Schools | Wharton, LBS, Kellogg, IESE, NUS, etc. | ESADE, ESCP, WU Vienna, ESSEC, etc. | Part of the Global Network for Advanced Management (GNAM) |
No. of Countries | 25+ | 4–5 primary locations across Europe | 5+ (rotates annually within GNAM schools) |
Global Credits Transferable? | Yes – towards graduation & specialization | Integrated into academic curriculum | Immersion is graded but not always credit-bearing |
Key Insight:
ISB offers the widest exchange network, great for younger professionals seeking international electives.
IIMA and IIMB integrate mandatory international modules, ideal for mid-level professionals seeking targeted global business exposure.
ISB vs IIM Specializations & Career Tracks
Feature | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMB EPGP |
Specialization Options | Functional (Finance, Marketing, Ops, Strategy), Cross-functional (Product, Analytics, Sustainability, etc.) | Chosen through electives – deep academic tracks | No formal majors; choose across electives |
Capstone / Final Project | Real-world projects with firms, plus electives-led immersion | Capstone simulation + final group integration project | Mandatory capstone project based on live industry problem |
Career Services Alignment | Career Coaching + Alumni Mentorship + Industry Connects | Individualized support through placement office | Career workshops + 1:1 mentoring + entrepreneurship exit |
Is ISB MBA better than IIM?
ISB offers maximum flexibility with a broad curriculum, making it ideal for career switchers or explorers.
IIMA PGPX delivers intellectual depth and structure, suited for professionals doubling down on leadership.
IIMB EPGP is industry-connected, immersive, and ideal for domain expansion with global flavor.
Choose based on how much structure, depth, and global exposure your career stage demands — and how you want your next year to stretch you.
International Exposure and Global Immersion Programs:
Global exposure is a vital component of modern business education. IIMs and ISB both recognize the value of international perspectives. They provide various global immersion programs to enhance learning experiences.
IIMs offer partnerships with foreign universities. These collaborations allow for student exchanges and global study tours. Such initiatives foster a broader understanding of international business practices.
ISB emphasizes international exposure through its international exchange programs. It collaborates with leading global business schools. These partnerships enable students to experience diverse cultural and economic environments.
Participation in these programs enriches students' global outlook. It also enhances their adaptability in a multicultural business landscape. Such exposure is invaluable for those aspiring to compete in a global market.
20. Cost of MBA: IIM vs. ISB – A Detailed Breakdown
Fees of IIM vs ISB 2024:
ISB MBA Fees: INR 41.5 Lacs to INR 44 Lacs (depending on type of accommodation & payment plans)
IIMA PGPX One year MBA for Executives Fees: INR 31.5 Lacs to 33.5 Lacs (depending on type of accommodation & payment plans)
IIMB EPGP One year MBA for Executives Fees: INR 30 Lacs to 32 Lacs (depending on type of accommodation & payment plans)
Cost Comparison: ISB vs. IIM Ahmedabad PGPX
Aspect | ISB (PGP 2025-26) | IIM Ahmedabad PGPX (2025-26) |
Program Duration | 1 Year | 1 Year |
Base Fee (Tuition + Accommodation) | ₹32.77L - ₹35.45L | ₹34.15L - ₹36.20L |
Additional Expenses (Books, Meals, etc.) | ₹6.45L | ₹6.45L (Estimated) |
International Program Cost | ₹4.5L (Optional) | Extra for IIP |
Total Estimated Cost (Excluding IIP) | ₹34.72L - ₹37.70L | ₹40.60L - ₹42.65L |
Total Estimated Cost (With International Program) | ₹39.22L - ₹42.20L | ₹40.60L+ (Varies based on IIP) |
ISB offers a wide range of scholarships as compared to the IIM one year MBA programs till date.
Scholarships and Financial Aid ISB vs IIM
Why Scholarships Matter in One-Year MBA Programs
With tuition fees ranging from ₹25–40 lakhs, scholarships are not just about affordability — they also reflect how schools encourage diversity, merit, and impact. Let’s break down how ISB, IIM Ahmedabad (PGPX), and IIM Bangalore (EPGP) structure their financial aid.
IIMA PGPX – Scholarships Overview
Scholarships awarded both at entry and graduation.
Amounts are fixed as a percentage of tuition.
Granted by IIMA's Financial Aid Committee based on profile, contribution, and performance.
IIMA Scholarship Types
Type | Eligibility / Description | Amount | Stage |
Entry Scholarships | Defense, govt employees, non-male, foreign passport holders, social sector, disabled, arts/sports | 25% of tuition | On admission |
Graduation Awards | Based on academic performance, participation, leadership during the program | 15% of tuition | At graduation |
ISB vs IIM Scholarships Comparative Snapshot 2025:
Criteria | ISB PGP | IIMA PGPX | IIMB EPGP |
Coverage Range | 25% to 100% of tuition | 25% (entry), 15% (graduation) | ₹3L–₹6L waivers |
Scholarship Type | Merit, need, diversity, impact | Diversity, social contribution, merit | Merit, diversity, academic |
Need-Based Support | Extensive | For specific categories | Limited (via diversity) |
Donor-Based/Named Scholarships | 15+ donor-funded categories | Not explicitly listed | Not specified |
Post-Admission Scholarships | Social impact & CGPA-based | CGPA-linked (15% waiver) | Based on Term 2 CGPA |
Application Requirement | Some require essays + documents | Mostly automatic | Varies by round |
Is ISB better than IIM for MBA?
ISB offers the most extensive and flexible scholarship ecosystem — especially valuable for younger professionals from non-traditional or underrepresented backgrounds.
IIMA PGPX scholarships reward both diversity at entry and academic excellence at graduation, tailored to high-impact and mid-career candidates.
IIMB EPGP offers structured entry and mid-program scholarships focused on merit and academic consistency.
Choose based on not just the waiver value — but the fit between your profile and the scholarship philosophy of each institution.
Share your profile with us and schedule a call with an MBA admission consultant at GOALisB to discuss your chances at these top tier business schools in India. Get in touch with us on whatsapp at +91 7719497187 or email us at contact@goalisb.com.
ISB vs IIM: Summary Verdict Table
Which Program is Right for You?
If you're deciding between ISB and the top IIM one-year MBA programs (PGPX, EPGP, MBAEx, IPMX), this table offers a quick comparison based on your background and goals.
Criteria | ISB PGP | IIM One-Year MBAs (PGPX, EPGP, etc.) |
Ideal Work Experience Range | 2–8 years | 4–15 years |
Average Class Work Experience | ~4.1 years | ~7.5–8.5 years |
Class Size | ~800+ (diverse, larger cohort) | 70–160 (tight-knit, senior cohort) |
Average Age | ~26 | 30–32 |
GMAT/GRE Accepted? | Yes | Yes (GMAT/GRE; some accept CAT or internal test) |
Global Ranking (FT 2025) | 27 (ISB) | IIMA - 47, IIMB - 52, IIMC - 67 |
International Immersion | Optional – 50+ global partners | Mandatory immersion (IIMA, IIMB, IIMC) |
Scholarship Opportunities | Broad – need, merit, diversity, donor-based | Structured – entry and in-program merit/diversity awards |
Specialization Flexibility | High (Electives across 10+ areas) | Moderate (Fixed curriculum + electives) |
Career Services Rank (FT) | 19 (ISB) | IIMA - 43, IIMB - 60, IIMC -18 |
Best For | Career switchers, fast-trackers, diverse peer learning | Experienced professionals, domain leaders, senior managers |
Verdict: Choose ISB if you’re looking to pivot industries or functions early in your career. Choose an IIM one-year MBA if you’re a seasoned leader seeking strategic repositioning or senior leadership roles.
Making the Decision: IIM vs ISB Comparison
Choosing between IIM and ISB is a significant decision for many aspiring business leaders. Each institution offers distinct advantages, and the choice depends on individual goals. It's crucial to consider various factors before making a decision.
First, examine the curriculum offered by IIMs and ISB. Both institutions provide comprehensive MBA programs, but their focus areas and teaching methodologies differ.
Determine which program aligns more closely with your career aspirations and learning style.
Next, consider the alumni network. IIMs have an extensive network across diverse industries, which can offer broad career opportunities. ISB's alumni network is also robust, with strong connections in corporate and entrepreneurial sectors. Networking potential is vital for post-graduation success.
Placements and salary outcomes are another key consideration. IIMs and ISB have impressive placement records, attracting top companies. Analyze the types of roles and industries graduates usually enter, as well as the salary packages offered. These insights can help measure the potential return on investment.
Location might also play a role in your decision. IIMs have campuses across India, while ISB is primarily based in Hyderabad and Mohali. Consider how proximity to industrial hubs might influence internship and job opportunities.
Here are a few additional factors to weigh:
Program Length and Flexibility: Is the program duration suitable for your needs?
Faculty Expertise: Does the faculty's industry experience meet your expectations?
Global Exposure: Does the school offer sufficient international experiences?
Each of these elements contributes to the overall fit of the institution with your personal and professional goals. Evaluating them carefully will lead to an informed decision.
Aligning Personal Goals with Institutional Offerings
It's vital for prospective students to align their personal goals with what IIM or ISB offers. Start by clearly defining what you want from your MBA. This might include career advancement, a career change, or skill enhancement.
Research the strengths and weaknesses of each program. IIMs are known for their diverse specializations and rigorous academic environment. On the other hand, ISB emphasizes a global perspective and entrepreneurial spirit.
Consider the teaching methods that each institution employs. If you prefer case-based learning, ISB might suit you better. However, if you're inclined towards intensive coursework, an IIM program could be ideal.
Moreover, factor in the culture and environment. Do you thrive in a competitive atmosphere like that at IIMs? Or do you prefer the collaborative and innovative setting at ISB? Reflect on these aspects to ensure a good match.
Step-by-Step Guide for Career Changers to choose between IIM vs ISB:
Choosing between IIM and ISB requires a structured approach. Here’s a step-by-step guide to aid decision-making:
Assess Goals: Clarify what the student wants to achieve with an MBA, such as specific career goals or skill sets.
Research Options: Investigate IIMs and ISB thoroughly, understanding their program features, strengths, and campus culture.
Evaluate Requirements: Review admission criteria, ensuring alignment with the student's qualifications and experience level.
Consult Resources: Use counseling tools and speak with alumni for insider perspectives on the benefits and drawbacks of each institution.
Each step should be approached with patience and thoroughness. This process can significantly aid in making a choice that best supports one's future aspirations. By following this guide, one can confidently navigate the complexities of business education selection.
Which Business School to Choose?
The choice between IIM and ISB is not a straightforward one, as both offer world-class business education. Each has unique attributes catering to different student needs and aspirations. Your decision should align with your career objectives, personal preferences, and professional background.
IIMs boast a long-standing reputation and vast alumni networks, which can be particularly beneficial for certain industries and traditional corporate roles. Their diverse programs and well-established infrastructure support a comprehensive learning experience.
Conversely, ISB offers a global perspective and innovative curriculum that suits those looking for a modern business education. Its focus on entrepreneurship and leadership is appealing to professionals aiming for dynamic corporate roles or starting their ventures.
In making this decision, prioritize what aspects of a business school experience matter most to you. Whether it’s the international exposure at ISB or the prestigious legacy of IIMs, weigh these against your aspirations.
Ultimately, both paths can lead to successful careers but require a thoughtful consideration of what each institution offers compared to what you desire for your future.
Frequently asked questions about IIM vs ISB:
Is IIM A better than ISB?
Both IIM Ahmedabad and ISB are premier business schools in India but cater to different applicant profiles and career goals. IIM Ahmedabad's PGP primarily targets fresh graduates or those with limited work experience, while ISB's PGP is designed for mid-career professionals with 2-5 years of experience. According to the FT MBA 2024 rankings, IIM Ahmedabad ranks higher globally at number 41, while ISB is ranked at number 31, showcasing ISB's strength in international metrics like salary increase (229% for ISB vs. 141% for IIM A) and alumni network. Choosing between them depends on your career stage, goals, and desired outcomes.
Is ISB the best MBA in India?
ISB is one of the top-ranked MBA programs in India, frequently competing with IIM Ahmedabad, Bangalore, and Calcutta. It ranks at number 31 in the FT MBA 2024 rankings, above all other Indian schools, and boasts an impressive weighted salary of $174,421 with a 229% salary increase. Its international faculty (40%) and global collaborations make it particularly attractive to mid-career professionals. While "best" is subjective, ISB's one-year program is considered one of the finest for experienced professionals seeking global exposure and career acceleration.
What is the salary of IIM graduates after 5 years?
IIM graduates' salaries after 5 years vary based on their program, industry, and location. For top-tier IIMs like Ahmedabad, Bangalore, and Calcutta, the average weighted salary reported in the FT MBA 2024 rankings is:
IIM Ahmedabad: $194,595 (~₹1.50 crore annually)
IIM Bangalore: $167,425 (~₹1.39 crore annually)
IIM Calcutta: $161,676 (~₹1.34 crore annually)
These figures are typically achieved by graduates in consulting, finance, and technology roles. International placements often exceed these averages, crossing ₹1.5-2 crore annually.
Ready to accelerate your career trajectory with an IIM or an ISB MBA? GOALisB's expert consultants can help you navigate the admissions process and achieve your professional goals. Schedule a consultation with GOALisB!
